Celtic’s recent victory over Ross County proved to be one of the most challenging matches Brendan Rodgers has faced in the Scottish Premiership this season. The late goal, scored by Nicolas Kuhn, kept Rodgers’ winning streak intact, generating considerable excitement among the fans. However, amidst the celebration, former Celtic goalkeeper Pat Bonner took the opportunity to address misconceptions surrounding the roles of Reo Hatate and Paulo Bernardo within the team.
Rodgers chose to bench Bernardo in favor of Hatate for the match against Ross County, which sparked a debate among fans and commentators alike. Bonner felt compelled to clarify the misunderstanding that has arisen regarding the defensive capabilities of both players. He emphasized that labeling Hatate as a superior defensive option to Bernardo is misguided, as neither player primarily assumes a defensive role.
In his remarks on BBC Radio Scotland, Bonner explained, “The discussion that Reo Hatate is a better choice for defense over Paulo Bernardo is misplaced. When I think of a defensive player, I envision someone who provides substantial support to Callum McGregor in midfield, particularly when the team is under pressure.” His point highlights the distinction between traditional defensive duties and the creative play both Hatate and Bernardo offer.
Addressing the attacking strengths of the two players, Bonner expressed his admiration for Hatate’s versatility and creativity. “Reo Hatate is an exceptional talent who thrives in offensive situations, making significant passes and moving dynamically across the pitch,” he noted. Similarly, Bonner clarified that Bernardo’s effectiveness comes from his ability to implement counter-pressing tactics, which differs from a more conventional defensive strategy that requires maintaining an organized shape.
Brendan Rodgers has praised Hatate as “outstanding” following his performance against Kilmarnock earlier this season, and he acknowledged Bernardo as a pivotal player in the win over Ross County. Both players have shown impressive stats this season, with Hatate contributing two goals and an assist, while Bernardo has matched that output despite playing one less match.
The origins of the debate surrounding their defensive capabilities remain unclear. It may stem from Celtic’s overall aggressive defensive style, which can create the impression that both Hatate and Bernardo are primarily defensive players. However, fans are well aware of their attacking contributions in crucial moments, such as Bernardo’s decisive play in last season’s Scottish Cup final and Hatate’s impactful goals against Rangers. Ultimately, both players should be recognized for their attacking prowess rather than being confined to defensive labels.