As the excitement builds for the upcoming 2024 AFL Draft, it’s an ideal moment to look back at the top 10 picks from the 2016 draft class. Nearly a decade later, this talented group has shaped AFL landscapes, with all but one player still actively listed. Yet, despite their early promise, only three of them remain with the clubs that originally drafted them. Let’s dive into where these players are now and how their careers have evolved.
Andrew McGrath (Essendon)
Andrew McGrath entered the AFL as a highly regarded junior player, quickly establishing himself with Essendon by winning the 2017 Rising Star award. Known for his leadership, McGrath joined the Bombers’ leadership group in 2021, growing into a key player in their defense. As an elite small defender, he’s expected to take on an even larger role as a leader within the team, with a contract that keeps him at Essendon until the end of 2030.
Tim Taranto (Richmond)
Tim Taranto, originally drafted by GWS, made a significant impact early on, winning the Kevin Sheedy Medal in 2019 during GWS’s grand final campaign. After five strong years, he sought more midfield opportunities and moved back to Victoria, signing a long-term contract with Richmond. In his first season with the Tigers, he was named best and fairest in 2023, helping to steer the team through a challenging rebuild as they work toward becoming a premiership contender once again.
Hugh McCluggage (Brisbane)
Hugh McCluggage has been a consistent force for Brisbane, culminating in a premiership win in 2024. Known for his elusive style and skillful play in the midfield, he’s often compared to Brisbane legend Simon Black. Despite narrowly missing All-Australian selections several times, McCluggage remains a key figure for the Lions, with a contract extending through 2027, ensuring his place in their long-term plans.
Ben Ainsworth (Gold Coast)
Ben Ainsworth has shown steady improvement since his debut, making him a standout from Gold Coast’s 2016 draft selections. A versatile small forward, he stepped up his game in 2024, bringing energy and resilience to the Suns’ quest to reach the finals. Committed to the club for the long term, Ainsworth has resisted offers from clubs in his home state of Victoria, proving his dedication to Gold Coast’s future.
Will Setterfield (Essendon)
Will Setterfield’s AFL journey has been a winding one, spanning three clubs. Starting with GWS, he soon moved to Carlton, where he developed under top players but found competition for spots fierce. A recent trade to Essendon has given Setterfield a fresh opportunity to carve out his role. Though not always in the spotlight, he’s earned a contract extension through 2025, highlighting his continued potential as a role player under coach Brad Scott.
Each of these players has followed a unique path, with various challenges, transfers, and career highs shaping their journey since 2016. As they continue to evolve and make their mark on the AFL, their experiences provide a fascinating perspective on the unpredictable, dynamic nature of professional football careers.